Consecutive playoff series won by Penguins

Can ace trump Cards?

Posted by Eric Fisher On October 6

One game. The whole season comes down to one game
If the Phillies win Friday night, we will all take a deep sigh of relief and move on to the National League Championship Series.

If the Phillies lose, all that came before it will be virtually meaningless. The franchise-record 102 wins? They won’t matter. Cliff Lee‘s incredible undefeated months with miniscule ERAs? Lost in the misery of Lee blowing a 4-0 lead in Game 2. Hunter Pence‘s energy, enthusiasm and production? Let us know when he wins a playoff series.

If the Phillies lose Game 5 of the NL Divisional Series, the significance of all their regular-season accomplishments will collapse like a house of cards. Oops. Cards might not be the best metaphor these days.

The good news is that the Phillies have their ace on the mound. Games like this are why the Phillies acquired Roy Halladay.

Halladay gave up three runs in the first inning of Game 1. After a leadoff single in the second inning, Halladay retired the next 21 batters he faced. It would be wonderful to see Halladay extend that streak to … hmmmm … 48 batters. Or, instead of a perfect game, maybe he could merely produce a no-hitter to serve as a bookend to his playoff no-hitter against the Reds last year. But that’s asking too much.

Halladay won’t shy away from carrying the burden of expectations, but he can’t carry the whole load himself. The rest of the team will have to help by producing at least a run or two.

You see, although I haven’t mentioned them yet, there will be another team on the field. The Cardinals are a pretty good team. As good as Halladay is, you can’t count on him throwing a shutout against a lineup that includes Albert Pujols, Lance Berkman and Matt Holliday, who returned to full-time action in Game 4. Less heralded is the second base tandem of Skip Schumaker and Ryan Theriot, both of whom are batting .600 or above in this series. And let’s not forget David Freese, who kept the Phillies’ celebration champagne on ice with four RBI in Game 4.

There also will be another pitcher on the mound. Chris Carpenter isn’t Halladay, but he is the Cardinals’ ace. The Phillies chased Carpenter after three innings in Game 2, but this time Carpenter won’t be pitching on short rest.

The way the Phillies are swinging the bats, even Carpenter on short rest might be a difficult obstacle to overcome. Heck, the way the Phillies are swinging the bats, facing Chris Wheeler on short rest might be a challenge. Since chasing Carpenter with four early runs in Game 2, the Phillies have only scored six runs, three of them on an unlikely pinch-hit homer by Ben Francisco, who hadn’t homered in his previous 108 at-bats.

If there’s an area of concern for the Phillies, it’s their everyday lineup. The top of the lineup is exempt from criticism. Jimmy Rollins is batting .563 in the NLDS; Chase Utley is batting .462. Rollins, Utley and Pence (.267), not surprisingly, combined to produce the Phillies’ first two runs in Game 4 before Cardinals starter Edwin Jackson had recorded an out. The problem is the Phillies only produced four hits the rest of the game, one of them by pinch-hitter Ross Gload. The only other run scored when Michael Martinez, pinch-running for Gload, scored on a wild pitch.

The rest of the starting lineup has been terrible the past three games. Even with an 11-run output in Game 1, nobody batting from fourth to eighth in the order is batting above .250.

Ryan Howard is batting .133. He sparked the offense in Game 1 with a three-run homer to put the Phillies ahead, but he went 0-for-8 in St. Louis with five strikeouts. Shane Victorino is batting .250 for the series, as is Raul Ibanez, who looked awful while striking out three times during Game 4. Placido Polanco raised his average to .125 by going 1 for 4 in Game 4. Carlos Ruiz is batting .071 for the series.

The failure of the middle lineup explains why the Phillies aren’t scoring runs despite the top two hitters in their lineup getting on base in half their at-bats. The failure of the bottom of the lineup robs the Phillies of the boost they’ve frequently received — and we’ve come to expect — in the postseason from players such as Ruiz.

The Cardinals’ weakness entering this series was supposed to be their bullpen. Not only have the Phillies failed to exploit that supposed weakness, but Cardinals relievers have stymied them the past three games. After Carpenter was chased from Game 2, Cardinals relievers shut out the Phillies for six innings, allowing St. Louis to rally for the victory and avoid falling into a 2-0 series hole. The Phillies managed two hits against five Cardinals relievers during Game 4, scratching out a run on a wild pitch.

Let’s hope the Phillies get another shot at the Cardinals bullpen. That would mean they did enough damage to force Carpenter out of the game.

The offensive outlook appears bleak; however, Phillies fans can take solace in the fact that Halladay will be on the mound. There might not be a pitcher in baseball who would be a better choice to pitch a winner-take-all playoff game.

Sometimes a lone ace can trump all the other cards. The Phillies may need their ace to trump the Cards in Game 5.

And, right now, after 166 games, Game 5 is the only game that matters.


Shop for Philadelphia Phillies Gear at Shop.MLB.com!

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

7 Responses

  1. PhillyPhanatics.com columns - Chronological list & links | Philly Phanatics - THE online community for Philly sports fanatics Says:

    […] Can ace trump Cards? (10/6/11) […]

    Posted on October 7th, 2011 at 9:55 am

  2. Philadelphia Phillies posts - Chronological list & links | Philly Phanatics - THE online community for Philly sports fanatics Says:

    […] Can ace trump Cards? (10/6/11) […]

    Posted on October 7th, 2011 at 9:57 am

  3. Matt Rosenbaum Says:

    After witnessing Detroit’s success last night in Yankee Stadium in the deciding game (and being thrilled at that result of course), I simultaneously thought about how easily the Yankees fate could befall our beloved Phils. Our slumping hitters must do SOMETHING! Even if Halladay gives up only two, the pressure will mount if we keep stranding Jimmy and Chase and what if they go cold too?! It’s great Ryan got us going in Game 1 and Ben luckily – very, very luckily – bailed us out in Game 3 but, uh, this is scary. Cards might upset us as San Fran did last year. So two questions: Are our hitters overmatched, impatient, or just pressing? Can you allay my fears that Halladay will be shut them down and we’ll explode in front of the home crowd?

    Posted on October 7th, 2011 at 12:58 pm

  4. Ron Opher Says:

    Matt –

    I’ll admit in watching Joe Giradi’s press conference last night, it looked like he didn’t know what hit him – and in that moment, I could envision Charlie Manuel sitting there with the same stunned and dejected look.

    That being said, I don’t think Roy Halladay will allow that to happen. The hitting has been maligned all season, and I’d love for them to be more productive, but the cold, hard reality is that the Phillies are in this predicament because Cliff Lee and Roy Oswalt each gave up 5 runs in 6 innings. Lee’s outing, in particular, was inexcusable after being handed a 4-0 lead. If Lee did his job, we may have – like last year – had the only sweep of the Division Series. Of the 4 starters, only Hamels pitched below his season and team’s ERA. If the team is built with the premise that the pitching leads and the offense follows, the pitchers have only led the charge in one of the 4 games.

    I expect that if a shutout is needed, that’s what Doc must deliver. And I expect it. Or else I’ll have the same stunned look as Girardi had – and Manuel would have.

    Posted on October 7th, 2011 at 1:54 pm

  5. Matt Rosenbaum Says:

    Now a couple million Phils fans, including us, have the same stunned look as Girardi ’cause, as you said, we could have had a sweep, not a humbling, humiliating, baffling pre-mature(?) exit from the playoffs. Halladay didn’t get the shutout you said he could produce, if necessary (and even that would have left us with precarious extra innings). And now I’m watching the Cards hit confidently against the Brewers. Sheesh! Also, read Missanelli’s article today and let me know what you think as well.

    Posted on October 9th, 2011 at 5:48 pm

  6. Columns archive - Chronological list & links | Philly Phanatics - THE online community for Philly sports fanatics Says:

    […] Can ace trump Cards? (10/6/11) […]

    Posted on November 3rd, 2011 at 9:53 am

  7. Philadelphia Phillies archive - Chronological list & links | Philly Phanatics - THE online community for Philly sports fanatics Says:

    […] Can ace trump Cards? (10/6/11) […]

    Posted on February 14th, 2012 at 8:34 pm

Leave a Reply

Couturier scores Game 5 game-winner